Kirsty Maxwell had been in Benidorm for less than twelve hours when she died. The 27-year-old newlywed from Livingston, Scotland, had flown to Spain on April 28, 2017, with friends for a hen party. In the early hours of April 29, she fell from the tenth-floor balcony of an apartment at the Apartamentos Payma — an apartment she had mistakenly entered, which was occupied by five men from Nottingham she did not know.

That much is established. Almost everything else is disputed. The five men were questioned and released; a Spanish judge later ruled there was no criminality and shelved the case as an accident. Kirsty’s family — her husband Adam, her parents Brian and Denise — have never accepted that conclusion. They point to unanswered questions about how she came to be in that apartment, what happened inside it, and why the investigation, in their view, left crucial lines of inquiry unexplored. With the help of retired detective David Swindle, they have run their own investigation for years and appealed to the High Court in Madrid.

The case became a slow-burning cause célèbre in Scotland: an MTV true-crime documentary in 2021, podcast series, and regular press coverage of the family’s fight. The Spanish authorities’ position has not changed. The family’s has not either.

So what really happened on that Benidorm balcony? Was it a tragic accident — a young woman, a wrong door, a fatal fall — or did something happen in that apartment that no investigation has yet uncovered? Nine years on, Kirsty Maxwell’s family is still asking, and still waiting for an answer they can believe.

Kirsty had traveled with a large hen party — reports put the group at around twenty women — and the celebration was barely underway when the night turned. She became separated from her friends in the early hours and somehow entered the wrong apartment in the complex: a tenth-floor unit occupied by five men from Nottingham who were strangers to her. What happened inside that apartment in the minutes before she fell remains the central, unanswered question. The men were arrested, questioned, and released; Spanish investigators concluded there was no evidence of foul play.

Her family’s campaign has been relentless and public. Working with former detective David Swindle, they have highlighted what they call a catalogue of investigative failures — unexamined forensic opportunities, witnesses never traced, including an English-speaking couple said to have seen her body by the pool and a café customer who spoke of seeing a girl on the balcony. They took their challenge to the High Court in Madrid after a Spanish judge shelved the criminal probe. An MTV True Life Crime UK documentary in 2021 brought the case to a new audience, but the Spanish ruling stands: accident. The family’s answer stands too: not proven.

The family has also criticized the support they received abroad, saying they felt abandoned by consular services in the days after Kirsty’s death — a complaint that prompted wider scrutiny of how Britain assists families when citizens die overseas.

Sources:


Disclosure: The stories on Love Lies Abroad are based on publicly reported accounts. We are not stating these as facts — this is what was reported. If you are featured in a story and believe it is inaccurate, contact us and we will review it, correct it, or take it down.

Join the conversation

Load Facebook comments to read and reply using your Facebook account.

Are you mentioned in this story?
Submit a correction, documentation, context, or a response for private editorial review. Contact the editorial desk.