Sarm Heslop was 41, a former flight attendant from Southampton, England, who had reinvented herself as a chef in the luxury yacht industry. In 2020 she met Ryan Bane, an American from Michigan, on the dating app Tinder. By March 2021 the couple were working together aboard the Siren Song, a 47-foot catamaran anchored off St. John in the U.S. Virgin Islands, taking private charters through some of the most beautiful water in the Caribbean. Then, in the early hours of March 8, 2021, she vanished.

The evening had seemed ordinary. The couple went to dinner on St. John on March 7, observed earlier in the day by another couple on a nearby boat who said everything appeared calm. Because the island was under a COVID-19 curfew, they were expected back aboard by 10 p.m. The catamaran sat about 200 feet offshore, reachable only by dinghy.

Bane’s account is where the questions begin. He said Heslop was asleep by 10 p.m. and gone when he woke around 2:30 a.m. He took the dinghy ashore and contacted island police, who advised him to call the Coast Guard. But he did not call the Coast Guard until 11:45 a.m., a gap of more than nine hours that has haunted the case ever since. Her father has asked publicly what happened in those hours, and why no alarm was raised on the water.

Heslop’s phone, wallet, and passport were found aboard the catamaran. Law enforcement searched the coastline with drones, divers, and sniffer dogs. Nothing turned up. Bane allowed police onto the boat, but the vessel itself was never fully searched, and his attorney later advised against permitting a search. He received civil citations for registration and safety violations. No criminal charges were ever filed, and Bane has always denied any involvement, suggesting through his lawyer that Heslop may have fallen overboard or drowned while swimming.

Her family in England has never accepted that explanation. The U.S. Virgin Islands police commissioner has publicly called the timeline suspicious. In 2025, police released CCTV footage of the couple’s last recorded movements together, walking down a dock hours before she disappeared, in a renewed appeal for information. A BBC documentary, Missing in Paradise: Searching for Sarm, brought the case to a new audience.

More than five years on, there is no body, no charge, and no confirmed explanation. A woman met a man on Tinder, built a life with him on a yacht in paradise, and vanished from it in the night. The Siren Song still floats in memory; Sarm Heslop does not.

The case might have faded if not for the persistence of her family and a 2025 BBC documentary, Missing in Paradise: Searching for Sarm, which released police CCTV footage showing the couple’s last recorded movements: walking side by side down a wooden dock, boarding the dinghy back to the yacht, six hours before she was reported missing. Her mother, Brenda Street, told the BBC she had come to accept that her daughter was dead, but that the family still could not grieve properly without knowing what happened.

The U.S. Virgin Islands police commissioner has said publicly that the timeline Bane provided is suspicious and that investigators still want to speak with him. Bane’s attorney has called that characterization irresponsible, maintaining there is no evidence of his involvement and suggesting Heslop may have hit her head and fallen overboard. Dateline NBC covered the case in an episode titled Siren Song. More than five years after that March night, the catamaran has new chapters in its log. Sarm Heslop’s story still has no ending.

Sources: Wikipedia: Disappearance of Sarm Heslop; TV Lineups / Dateline


Disclosure: The stories on Love Lies Abroad are based on publicly reported accounts. We are not stating these as facts — this is what was reported. If you are featured in a story and believe it is inaccurate, contact us and we will review it, correct it, or take it down.

Join the conversation

Load Facebook comments to read and reply using your Facebook account.

Are you mentioned in this story?
Submit a correction, documentation, context, or a response for private editorial review. Contact the editorial desk.