Carla Stefaniak flew to Costa Rica in November 2018 to celebrate her 36th birthday. She traveled with her sister-in-law, stayed in an Airbnb villa outside San Jose, and texted her family that the place felt, in her words, pretty sketchy. She was supposed to fly home on November 28. She never boarded the plane.

Stefaniak, who lived in Florida, had arranged a driver to collect her at 8:30 the next morning for the airport. When she didn’t appear, her family raised the alarm. Investigators found blood inside the Airbnb apartment where she had been staying, the Villa Buena Vista in the San Antonio de Escazu area. Search dogs then found her body half-buried in a wooded area a few hundred yards from the property, wrapped in plastic bags.

The autopsy told a brutal story: Stefaniak had suffered blunt force wounds to the head and multiple stab wounds to her neck and arms. Authorities described the attack as sexually motivated. Her final communication with her family had come around 8 p.m. on the night of November 27, when she mentioned she was going to ask a guard at the property for some water.

That guard, 32-year-old Bismarck Espinoza Martinez, a Nicaraguan immigrant working security at the complex, quickly became the focus of the investigation. Costa Rica’s Judicial Investigation Department said he contradicted himself in statements to police, and investigators found blood in his nearby apartment. He was arrested and charged with her murder.

In February 2020, Martinez was convicted of homicidio simple, second-degree murder, and sentenced to 16 years in prison, along with an order to pay the family roughly $53,000 in compensation. He was acquitted of the more serious first-degree murder charge, a verdict that devastated her family. Her father publicly called the sentence far too lenient, and the family’s lawyers had pushed for decades more behind bars.

Stefaniak’s family has never accepted that Martinez acted alone. They have said from the beginning that they believe more than one person was involved in her death, pointing to the distance her body was moved and the logistics of the attack. Costa Rican investigators, however, charged only Martinez, and the DNA evidence presented at trial pointed to him alone.

Her case became a cautionary tale about vacation rentals abroad: a woman alone in an unfamiliar property, a security guard who used his position to gain access to her room, and a family left to grieve across an international border. Carla Stefaniak went to Costa Rica for a birthday. She came home in a casket.

Stefaniak had not traveled alone. Her sister-in-law, April Antonieta, had come with her for the birthday trip but had to fly home a day early, leaving Carla alone for her final night. That evening, a heavy thunderstorm knocked out power at the property. According to Costa Rican reporting on the case, the security guard used his position to gain entrance to her villa, where he attacked her, stabbing her repeatedly when she resisted.

The family’s pursuit of accountability extended beyond the criminal case. They sued the Airbnb property’s owners and the American company handling the booking, alleging negligence and a failure to provide secure lodging. A Finding Carla Facebook page kept public attention on the case through the trial. And the family never wavered from their belief that the logistics of the killing, moving a 195-pound woman several hundred yards into the woods, pointed to more than one person, even though only Martinez was ever charged.

Sources: Oxygen; Travel Off Path


Disclosure: The stories on Love Lies Abroad are based on publicly reported accounts. We are not stating these as facts — this is what was reported. If you are featured in a story and believe it is inaccurate, contact us and we will review it, correct it, or take it down.

Join the conversation

Load Facebook comments to read and reply using your Facebook account.

Are you mentioned in this story?
Submit a correction, documentation, context, or a response for private editorial review. Contact the editorial desk.